Story and humor are inapplicable to this animation, so I won’t critique them.
This is another AMV but was solely made by one person, so it can be reviewed more objectively. The AMV is pretty good for the most part. Movements are fluid and beats are aligned with actions in the animation. They play off the lyrics to show events in the animation, which is also a nice touch. However, there could definitely be more lighting effects and dramatic scenes. When it comes to that of a music video, there definitely need to be steps to make the whole animation more artistic in quality. Though this animation functions well as an animation, there isn’t a lot of stylistic choices added or interesting elements to it. It’s still one of the better AMVs of SN I’ve seen, and anyone who likes that kind of content would enjoy it. It just lacks quite a bit and could be a lot more. Still was enjoyable, just has a lot of work to do.
Not a fan of the music, but looking aside that, this isn’t bad at all. There’s great syncing with the music as always from Mei and theres also some small little details hidden here and there. Overall this was done pretty cleanly. But theres a lack in visuals that keeps the viewer watching. This is important when the scenes taken are supposed to represent something. But great work overall. Just average entertainment value.
2/5
Story and humor are inapplicable to this animation, so I won’t critique them.
This is another AMV but was solely made by one person, so it can be reviewed more objectively. The AMV is pretty good for the most part. Movements are fluid and beats are aligned with actions in the animation. They play off the lyrics to show events in the animation, which is also a nice touch. However, there could definitely be more lighting effects and dramatic scenes. When it comes to that of a music video, there definitely need to be steps to make the whole animation more artistic in quality. Though this animation functions well as an animation, there isn’t a lot of stylistic choices added or interesting elements to it. It’s still one of the better AMVs of SN I’ve seen, and anyone who likes that kind of content would enjoy it. It just lacks quite a bit and could be a lot more. Still was enjoyable, just has a lot of work to do.
Low 3/5.
PL Team Slave OwnerNot a fan of the music, but looking aside that, this isn’t bad at all. There’s great syncing with the music as always from Mei and theres also some small little details hidden here and there. Overall this was done pretty cleanly. But theres a lack in visuals that keeps the viewer watching. This is important when the scenes taken are supposed to represent something. But great work overall. Just average entertainment value.
2/5