Story and humor are inapplicable to this animation, so I won’t critique them.
This is a hard animation to critique because the sole focus of it is on the voice tests for the Transformers and less of anything to do with the animation. As such, this can’t exactly be reviewed with only animation perspectives in mind. Since I am not as well-versed with voice acting as I am with animation and cinema, I will instead rate based on my overall impression.
The voices are somewhat decent on their own part, but there is a clear dependency upon the filters rather than the voices themselves. It’s a bit too much to expect, however, since this is being made casually by an SN animator.
Overall, I enjoyed the voices though. It isn’t something I would go out of my way to find, but it was interesting while it lasted. It could be a lot more, but I appreciated it for what it is.
For a test animation, it’s pretty good. Voices work along with the animation. While the voice acting to me is not something I’m a fan of, it’s something I can’t expect much of considering this is all without a budget and all sorts of limitations. But the angles and animation itself isn’t bad. It compliments the dialogue.
3/5
Story and humor are inapplicable to this animation, so I won’t critique them.
This is a hard animation to critique because the sole focus of it is on the voice tests for the Transformers and less of anything to do with the animation. As such, this can’t exactly be reviewed with only animation perspectives in mind. Since I am not as well-versed with voice acting as I am with animation and cinema, I will instead rate based on my overall impression.
The voices are somewhat decent on their own part, but there is a clear dependency upon the filters rather than the voices themselves. It’s a bit too much to expect, however, since this is being made casually by an SN animator.
Overall, I enjoyed the voices though. It isn’t something I would go out of my way to find, but it was interesting while it lasted. It could be a lot more, but I appreciated it for what it is.
Low 3/5.
PL Team Slave OwnerFor a test animation, it’s pretty good. Voices work along with the animation. While the voice acting to me is not something I’m a fan of, it’s something I can’t expect much of considering this is all without a budget and all sorts of limitations. But the angles and animation itself isn’t bad. It compliments the dialogue.
3/5