I don’t label myself anything of classy. I maybe started but I will admit people like you have pulled me off of that.
There is one point you made which you got something on.
I could approach this better. What started off as confusion at where this stuff has gone nowhere.

You said you saw there is an issue with this post and the likes towards it. However I don’t think I have said anything that strays from the idea of “where are people getting this idea.”

Could go on and I still got issues with you and how you approach things. But we will figure that out in time.
As of right now I will work on what you mentioned.

I am still confused where the ego thing and trivial stuff comes from.

None of this is about critique. If this was a post soley on “this could be improved.” I would not have an issue, I would love it.
This post is an issue as it is straight slander and gives nothing other than to paint someone in a bad light.

The last sentence is wrong. You said 0 about how I could improve things.
You threw mud about a thing I put in descriptions and brought up this idea that I want to be praised for every individual thing because I apparently think I am the best at everything?

My friend, you made a post out of nowhere attacking me on trivial things you don’t understand and labeled me as egotistical. I did nothing and you attacked me. If I were Epitaph, I would not have been attacked as hard as you attacked me over a decription detail and this fabrication that I am egotistical. Grooming kids is messed up and wrong, thats why I used that example. You are doing gymnastics around a point.

Fair point.
I’m a little pissed and I can stay beyond what Gigan does. However, much if it still applies and even though you aren’t the one to talk about insults, a point is a point.

You made a comment with an insult right off the bat.
“Also he tends to have a thick skull”
You then make paddle an idea that I am egotistical and that you slowly started to dislike me over these things. You never had any sign of that and never relayed it to me. You relayed it to other people in a slanderous way right off a comment that should have never been made pointing out trivial things that boil down to a lack of understanding as to why it is there.

None of that is civil. However you have a change in tone in your post here. I will respect that.

A script is not screenplay. I always was typing scripts in the sense of getting the bones down and building on it. They actually are not supposed to be full. A script tells you what the dialogue is and the actions in the scene on a basic level, a screenplay tells you how exactly the scene will play out in detail. You probably were looking for screenplay. You however never told me that wasn’t enough.
I too could honestly say 100% of the things you say about PL toward your series. It is all anecdotal.

Sitting there and giving praise then saying it “barely improved and was boring” is on par with giving Rise of Skywalker for improving on the Last Jedi praise.
A critic is critical.

You are still missing the issue here though. You had a thing about ego and aren’t addressing that.

And yes, SN movie absolutely had a honeymoon phase. In the early days of SN it was impressive for the time, but dated later. Epitaph and his inserts of fetishes we all blew off as just Epitaph being Epitaph. Now that we know who he is as a person, that perspective changes because it was worse than that.
PL Episode 1 had that same issue minus fetishes. PL Episode 2 fixed many issue and set the tone right, but like anything there is still issues.
Episode 3 cleared all that and more. I can still watch episode 3 and enjoy the action of it.
Episode 4 was a tremendous improvement at every corner. The feedback was overwhelmingly positive and still is. The issues with it remain with the episodes before it not holding up. Episode 4 on it’s own is a solid episode with actual meaningful dialogue.

Episode 4 was a giant change. Audio work was bumped up to 11, visuals were bumped up , writing also. There is issues with 4 that I can improve on, but you are basically giving me “what I make improved exponentially and what you made improved fractionally.”

I can’t do jack with that. Critique ain’t my issue here though.
It’s the fact you act as if I threw all of what you gave away. And then the fact you do exactly what you accuse me of. Acting as if your story is good and general series is interesting.
The author doesn’t decide that. The viewer does.

“I want to see your series succeed. It has great protentional to be one of the greatest stories every told in SN but theres so much its lacking.”
This is a nice thing to say and if you worked with this, you wouldn’t have as much of an issue. But if you really meant this, you wouldn’t be pulling this “EB is egotistical thing.”

So I will give you chance to prove this otherwise. On fresh posts you gotta point this stuff out. Continue with the tone you got now and we can figure this stuff out how it should have been in the first place.

Now that you have labeled me as egotistical and acted as if I never took any critique, you have lost my respect but I would like to see you change that. Slander is something that sets me off and if you are thinking of apologizing, don’t. I want to see what you have improve and you want to see what I have improve.

Lets find common ground here. Start from scratch, and deliver our critiques as they should be delivered.
We’re on different points here and aren’t going to get anywhere so let’s lock this down and get to the critique of each others stuff properly.

You win and I win.

And you act like a cancer on this community. You defend people based on who your friends are rather than what is right. You see drama and you fan the flames. You brought my attention to this post in a joking manner and I don’t think you are capable of ever reading a room because of that.

Every time someone is smeared out of nowhere, you chime in on that. How many of my close friends have ditched this whole site specifically because of you. With a comment like that, it shows that you are the problem. Not a thing was warranted here, it is petty shit that is 120% misunderstanding stuff I do.

I have given you the benefit of the doubt time and time again that you are better than what people say you are. You have lost that time and time again.

This isn’t acting like a wuss. This is approaching a problem head on. Have I been one to throw an insult? No, I have remained classy the whole time so I can figure out what the real issue is with me.

Now where the hell does that come from?
Let’s put that into context of what I actually said.
All I said is you people wouldn’t have gone after me as hard if I did what Epitaph did. I have done jack shit to piss people off this past bit but ones like yourself insist on digging up shit from the time of Abraham and distorting things that are said. There is never rational discussion with you miserable people.

The most appreciated animations out there are the most detailed. I don’t add details that nobody sees. All the small details I see in full speed and it comes together to create a solid animation. The idea you don’t see it is just wrong. People catch this stuff as the animation plays live and it just adds to existing quality.

On shadows, you have done it in all of your animations and I don’t feel like how it is used on characters has ever worked that well. Shading bleeds off edges to a glaring degree. You also do it with heavy use of ATF. That stuff all combined makes it easier to do in your animations not even including simpler figures with less limbs to track. Yet with all that I along with a couple other people agree that it just doesn’t work. A dabbled in what you did back in Episode 1 and there I knew it wouldn’t translate.
That is why I keep lighting more basic and limited to static subjects in the scene. Hell I experimented in Episode 4 and ran into an issue of versatility.

There is no contradiction. You are thinking in black and white.
I added more about the action into the script which I have in many areas followed. However finer details like how a bullet bounces off a combat bot aren’t included. Scripts at their core are supposed to deal with dialogue. Creative reasons means nothing more than finding out what can be done here and what can’t. Everything I do normally ends up being an experiment.

On dialogue, I ain’t tracking. Breaking things apart is absolutely false and has been since 3. I know that because I have always checked if dialogue can be said in the amount of time it is on screen for. If it is written right, length is not that much of a concern.

I could go on from here but that’s beyond any point here.
We are losing the plot of the real issue here. There’s multiple things I would like to figure out with you.
Biggest one is the ego thing and where you got that, especially when you sat there when episode 4 released and gave praise. Now it’s “barely improved,” so what changed?
Everyone was telling me it was a giant improvement over the last in every way. Suddenly now that isn’t the case with you specifically.
And you pat yourself on the back for your own animation, comparing yours to mine then accuse me of ego.

Nothing adds up here and theres a problem beyond “lack of improvement” and “ego.” You and I need to discuss as I don’t got a clue what you are on about and how you are reaching so hard on everything you say. This is all shit I should have heard of months ago. Either you haven’t been speaking your mind, or you there is some major misunderstanding.

I am partial to keeping things civil and discussing what is going on as this isn’t like you.